Columbus, OHAugust 25, 2026

"Who's the best insurance agency in Columbus?"

Who AI recommends for insurance agencies in Columbus

Measured August 25, 2026. Word for word.

No sponsored results. No business can pay to be on this list. We record what the AI engines actually say, word for word.

12NAMEDof22LISTED

Sealedinsurance_agency/columbus-oh

The standings

namednot namedno answer

Google AI: one row covering 2 surfaces, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Gemini: live, no receipt kept.

1

Horizon Insurance Services, Inc.

Named in 5 of 11 measured answers

5/11
ChatGPTGoogle AIGeminiPerplexity
From the answer, verbatim:
- **Horizon Insurance Services** — Columbus-based and explicitly says it insures Columbus and Ohio.

SealedAugust 25, 2026b546ca50-161

See the full recordIs this you? Claim your page free

2

W.E. Davis Insurance Agency

Named in 5 of 11 measured answers

5/11
ChatGPTGoogle AIGeminiPerplexity
From the answer, verbatim:
A solid **local recommendation** near Columbus is **W.E. Davis Insurance Agency** in Columbus, because it has a clearly listed local office, phone number, and business hours, which makes it easy to contact directly.

SealedAugust 25, 2026b546ca50-161

See the full recordIs this you? Claim your page free

4

ST

Named in 4 of 11 measured answers

4/11
ChatGPTGoogle AIGeminiPerplexity
From the answer, verbatim:
com/r/Columbus/comments/1ipd3dy/insurance_agent_recommendations/) generally recommend independent local options like Justice Insurance and Basil Insurance Group.

SealedAugust 25, 2026cc2cfca3-e62

See the full recordIs this you? Claim your page free

5

Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio

Named in 3 of 11 measured answers

3/11
ChatGPTGoogle AIGeminiPerplexity
From the answer, verbatim:
Slyman Insurance Group 5.

SealedAugust 25, 20269f9170cf-15f

See the full recordIs this you? Claim your page free

6

A.A. Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio

Named in 2 of 11 measured answers

2/11
ChatGPTGoogle AIGeminiPerplexity
From the answer, verbatim:
- **A.A. Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio** — **(614) 221-7007**.

SealedAugust 25, 2026dc447f76-63a

See the full recordIs this you? Claim your page free

8

Jonathan Yu - State Farm Insurance Agent

Named in 2 of 11 measured answers

2/11
ChatGPTGoogle AIGeminiPerplexity
From the answer, verbatim:
business**, your claims history, bundling, and whether you want an **independent broker** or a **captive agent** like State Farm/Allstate.

SealedAugust 25, 20263705f69f-b57

See the full recordIs this you? Claim your page free

10

Matic Insurance Services

Named in 1 of 11 measured answers

1/11
ChatGPTGoogle AIGeminiPerplexity
From the answer, verbatim:
- **Matic Insurance Services** — best if you want a digital-first shopping experience with lots of carrier options; it has a very large review footprint, but it may feel less like a traditional neighborhood agent.

SealedAugust 25, 20263705f69f-b57

See the full recordIs this you? Claim your page free

12

Sokol Eisenberg Insurance

Named in 1 of 11 measured answers

1/11
ChatGPTGoogle AIGeminiPerplexity
From the answer, verbatim:
- **Sokol Eisenberg Insurance** — **614-362-4262** — especially worth calling if this is **business/commercial insurance**; they describe themselves as locally owned since 1925 and focused on commercial coverage in Central Ohio.

SealedAugust 25, 20263f3df053-077

See the full recordIs this you? Claim your page free

The roll call · August 25, 2026

The night's roll call

Every business measured this week. The ones the answers named are lit.

12namedof22listed

  • Horizon Insurance Services, Inc.
  • Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC
  • W.E. Davis Insurance Agency
  • Acceptance Insurance
  • Isner Insurance Associates, Inc
  • Acceptance Insurance
  • ST
  • Catanzaro Insurance
  • Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio
  • Acceptance Insurance
  • A.A. Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio
  • J. R. Scott Insurance Agency
  • John Dawson Associates
  • Jonathan Yu - State Farm Insurance Agent
  • Compare Quote Insurance
  • Solid Insurance
  • Nikki Ogunduyile - State Farm Insurance Agent
  • Matic Insurance Services
  • Briggs & Williams Insurance Agency
  • Putnam White Lewis Insurance
  • Acceptance Insurance
  • Sokol Eisenberg Insurance

Being unnamed today is an observation with a date on it, not a judgment. Any of these businesses can run a free scan.

Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC · Acceptance Insurance · Acceptance Insurance — and 7 moreas listed on Google, fetched August 25, 2026

This record is 1 measured week(s) old. History accumulates weekly. Nothing here is padded to look busy.

The record, week by week

This history is captured live each week. It cannot be backfilled, by us or anyone.

  1. August 25, 2026 — 12 businesses named · 16 names could not be verified

The questions this week (General question pack — our standard 3 questions)

Real questions, asked the way customers ask, with no business name inside any question. Every named business below appeared in an actual AI answer, saved and dated.

"Who's the best insurance agency in Columbus, OH?"

"I need an insurance agency in Columbus, OH — who should I call?"

"Which insurance agency would you recommend near Columbus, OH?"

How this page is made

How this page is made: we ask 3 real customer questions across 5 AI engines: ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, and Google AI. Google AI is measured on 2 surfaces, AI Overviews and AI Mode, so 5 engines make 6 measured surfaces. A business is NAMED only when its name appears in the machine's actual answer text. Hinted at or linked does not count. Answers are saved word for word, dated, and content-hashed. No business name is ever inside a question, so no result can be nudged. Paying us never changes what the receipts say. This page is a set of dated observations: AI answers vary between runs.

August 25, 20265 of 5 surfaces measuredsealed bdea70d15e92

Own an insurance agency in Columbus? See what AI says about you in about a minute. Free, no card.

Run my free scan

Work with many local businesses? Introduce one and keep 50 percent of every subscription, recurring — paid by us, never added to their price.

See how referrals work

Appearify publishes this record. Businesses can pay us to help them get named. Nobody can pay us to be on this page.